Giving notices, and even announcing a hymn, before the greeting takes away from its impact.The only thing that should preface the opening greeting is the Trinitarian invocation.It should not be preceded or followed by more colloquial stock phrases of greeting, like ‘hello’, ‘good morning’, etc.It is the greeting that constitutes the liturgical assembly.It is important: do not rush it or belittle it.At the commencement, and at other high points of liturgy, the minister thus constitutes the church, and the people, in response, declare the human being before them to be their minister by grace.

It is a benediction that recognises the icon of Christ in the assembly of the baptized, and draws out this image, verbally constituting the ekklesia. The greeting is not a statement that Jesus is here so let’s get on with it. This is where I believe that the choice of the subjunctive in English is informative. It is important to speak about how we do, and should do, Dominus vobiscum. It is similar to the Eastern affirmation of a priest’s ordination by the acclamation of the people: axios, ‘worthy’. Other commentators have described the phrase as an acknowledgement of the spiritual grace given the ordained minister by the Holy Spirit. At its simplest, ‘your spirit’ is metonymy for ‘you’, and avoids the short, ungainly Et tecum, ‘And with you’ (even ‘And also with you’ uses extra syllables). A friend who is a Catholic priest commented to me that he finds the former translation - ‘And also with you’ - more affirming of his whole person than the new translation.Įt cum spiritu tuo is clearly not a direct reference to the Holy Spirit, as the Spirit does not belong to the minister. The new Catholic translation of the missal has taken us back closer to the original by using ‘And with your spirit’. The Epistles use this phrase at Galatians 6.18, Philippians 4.23, Philemon 25 and II Timothy 4.22. This paraphrase understands the use of the word ‘spirit’ as metonymy for the minister’s person or self.

The modern translation is clearly more of a paraphrase than a direct translation of the Latin. The traditional English translation of this is ‘And with thy spirit’, and the agreed ecumenical translation into contemporary English is ‘And also with you’. The Latin response to Dominus vobiscum is Et cum spiritu tuo. The Eastern churches have ‘Peace to all’ / ‘And with thy spirit’, but its use is different. This particular phrase is the greeting - the benediction - that constitutes the Christian assembly for worship. A major feature of a lot of liturgical language is that it is performative: it does something. The subjunctive is often used in blessing formulas, and this shows an important interpretation of this phrase: it is not about stating a fact - the Lord’s presence - but is the blessing of the Lord’s presence. Unlike much spoken English, and indeed written English, the subjunctive mood is on quite frequent duty in the Book of Common Prayer. Instead, our English reformers chose ‘The Lord be with you’, in the subjunctive mood. An obvious choice would have been to translate the phrase with ‘The Lord is with you’ (this is in the indicative mood). English needs the verb ‘to be’ to act as a copula. Grammatically, of course, the Latin original has no verb: Dominus vobiscum means, more literally, ‘Lord with you’. It can be clearly dated back to the 6th century (Council of Braga and, later, Gelasian Sacramentary), but can be inferred from the Apostolic Tradition and other early texts. The biblical references of Ruth 2.4, II Chronicles 15.2 and Matthew 28.20 are given in support of this phrase. It is also found before the reading of the Gospel, before a blessing, before blessing baptismal water, in the middle of Exsultet, and before praying a collect. ‘The Lord be with you’ is a presidential greeting, which is most often encountered at the beginning of the a liturgy and and the beginning of the eucharistic prayer.

Peace be with you in ukrainian